Slew Rate Measurement
Ever wonder what slew rate was all about? No, it has nothing to do with how a drunk person slurs their speech. This article gets to the basics of Amplifier Slew rate and what it means.
Whenreviewing the spec sheet of an amplifier, one potentially unfamiliar term youmay run into is slew rate. There area lot of gobbledygook explanations floating around the web which seem tomisunderstand the basic premise, so we at Audioholics are here to clear theair. In short, slew rate has little to do with how an amplifier producesdynamics so much as its ability to effectively maintain output into higherfrequencies. It is the rate of how quickly an amplifier can respond to a rapid change of input level. This is measured as a change in voltage with respect to time as can be seen in the main image of this article.
Digging Deeper
Thefirst thing that people tend to see in slew rate specification is that it ismeasured in volts/microsecond or v/usec. From there, people jump to theconclusion that an amplifier with a higher slew rate is more responsive,dynamic, etc. Since a picture is worth a thousand words, let’s take a look at arelatively simple graphic.
Depictedabove are sine waves of various frequencies; the lowest frequency is on topfollowed by sine waves of progressively higher frequency. You’ll notice that asyou go up in frequency, the value of the sine wave changes at a greaterrate than at lower frequencies: this is what slew rate is all about. Simply,slew rate tells us how high in frequency an amplifier can play for a givenvoltage level.
Sonow that we know what it is, how much slew rate is enough? The basic formula toobtain a minimum necessary slew rate for an amplifier is:
SlewRate = 2 x π x Frequency xPeak Voltage
As you’ll note, the factors we need to fill in are howhigh in frequency we want to go and how much output, as measured in volts, wewant to achieve.
So as a real world example, what is the bareminimum slew rate we need to effectively achieve THX Select 2 certification,which calls for peaks of up to 50V on all channels? Well, first we need toselect a frequency to base our calculation on; 20kHz would seem a good startingpoint, as this is the generally accepted upper limit of human hearing. Pluggingthose numbers in, you’ll find that a THX Select 2 amplifier should have a slewrate of no less than ~6.3V/usec if it aims to achieve full output at 20kHz.
Most well designed amplifiers are flat out to 100kHz soin that case you would need a minimum slew rate of about 32V/usec in order toachieve such a wide bandwidth.
Atthis point, an observer may note that the number calculated above is a lotlower than the specifications you are likely to encounter, even on entry levelreceivers. As an example, the Harman Kardon AVR 1565 boasts a slew rate of 40V/usec.Considering its rated power of 70W per channel into 8 ohms (the above exampleof 50V translates into a 312.5 watt peak at 8 ohms), 40V/microsecond wouldappear to be gross overkill. Realistically, it is a matter of good engineering.The bare minimum that we’re calculating is just that; most good linearamplifiers aim for flat response well beyond 20kHz, not because we can hearthat high or because we have loudspeakers capable of reproducing suchfrequencies effectively, but to ensure slew rate related problems are a totalnon-issue within the audible band. Simply put, once you start tossing in otherrequirements, i.e. expecting practically zero distortion even at full powerinto a difficult load at 20kHz (a problem area for some amplifiers, notablyClass D), a bit of extra margin in terms of slew rate can come in quite handy.
Withall this in mind, what are the real world consequences of a marginal slew rate?This question is a bit more difficult to answer, as a lot depends on the sourcematerial. It should be pointed out that unlike laboratory conditions, mostpeople aren’t running 20kHz sine waves through their systems at full output;real world material typically has little energy in the top octave (10kHz-20kHz),which can help mask the effects of a marginal slew rate. Odds are in and ofitself, slew rate is unlikely to be a limiting factor in an amplifier’s realworld performance; of course as mentioned above, if you’re expectingpractically perfect performance under all circumstances, extra margin doesn’thurt.
Editorial Note about Slew Rate from Sergiu Ignat – Electronics Designer for Classe
Slew Rate (SR) indeed expresses the ability of an amplifier to follow the input and as the formula implies this applies to the high frequencies within the passband of the amp. However most amplifiers have an input low pass filter used to minimize RF ingress and to limit slew rate induced distortions. Therefore even if the intrinsic SR of a power amp can be higher most designs tend to limit the bandwidth of the applied signal and in consequence the real SR may be lower than the one specified. If a manufacturer specifies “SR measured with input filter disabled” then it is the real deal.
By itself SR is a second order specification, not all manufacturers publish/measure it and is not indicative of sound quality if not accompanied by distortion numbers at the frequency of interest. For example an amplifier can follow a square wave at 20 kHz very closely in terms of rise/fall times, which in turn will give a very good SR number but if it does so with 20% overshoot and/or with long settling times (ringing that lasts for most of the pulse duration)…then the amplifier is probably not very good sonically (it has a hot and seemingly “detailed” top end).
The formula can be rewritten as: SR=2*π*f*√(2*P*Z)
This shows that if you need to deliver the same power at the same frequency into a higher load you need a higher SR. Considering the impedance swings of real world speakers we can see why having a healthy SR is not a bad idea as long as distortion and other parameters are kept in check.
On the other hand nobody expects a power amp to deliver full power at say 200kHz, the filter capacitors in the supply may not be able to sustain that kind of ripple current.
Classe CA-2300 Amplifier Internal View
In our detailed review of the Classe CT-2300, we measured impeccable performance in every aspect. The amplifier was wide bandwdith, low distortion and very capable of driving low impedance loads at high sustained outputs. This amplifier exhibited no slew rate induced problems.
Bynow you the reader should understand that slew rate has precious little to dowith the dynamics or punchiness of an amplifier, although one can imply that amore powerful amplifier requires a higher slew rate. Slew rate is all abouteffective bandwidth. Further, you’ll find that you don’t necessarily need a topechelon amplifier to extend useful bandwidth well beyond 20kHz. PresumingHarman Kardon isn’t fudging their specs too badly, the slew rate of the entrylevel AVR 1565 is sufficient to give it full power output to 100kHzand beyond, which even a conservative engineer would consider (in a dry tone)“adequate”. Of course, now equipped with the knowledge of how slew rate andbandwidth are intertwined, you too can see just how true some claims ofbandwidth out to 300kHz and beyond really are. Happy listening (andcalculating)!
Confused about what AV Gear to buy or how to set it up? Join our Exclusive Audioholics E-Book Membership Program!
Scott Weiner, post: 1093262, member: 75432
1. In a car audio amplifier, what is considered a good slew rate?
2. Most importantly, with all other things being equal, how is sound quality affected between amps where one amp has a much better slew rate than the other?
cyclebrain, post: 966024Sorry, but no, bandwidth has nothing to do with slew rate.
Exactly what I said. Given the same voltage swing, bandwidh and slew rate are directly related.
Steve81, post: 965953
One other way of wording it:
Amplifier Sound - What Are The Influences?
cyclebrain, post: 965887
What is the difference between slew rate and bandwidth?
Given a fixed voltage swing, only frequency will have an effect on rate of change.
cyclebrain, post: 965887
Slew Rate # : Closely related to power bandwidth, the slew rate is the maximum rate of change (measured in Volts per microsecond) of the amplifier output. The higher the amplifier power, the higher the slew rate must be to obtain the same power bandwidth.
联系客服
